PhD Thesis Defence of Sirja-Liisa Eelma

PhD Thesis Defence of Sirja-Liisa Eelma
Location:
EKA, A101
Start Date:
18.12.2026
Start Time:
10:00
End Date:
18.12.2026

On 18 December, 2026 Sirja-Liisa Eelma, doctoral student of Art and Design curriculum, will defend her doctoral thesis “Indra’s Net of Painting: Repetitions, Differences and Reflections” („Maalikunsti Indra võrk: kordused, erinevused ja peegeldused“).
The public defense will take place at 10.00 at EKA (Põhja pst 7), room A101.
The defence will be broadcast live on EKA TV.

Supervisor: Alari Allik, PhD (Tallinn University)
External reviewers: Elnara Taidre, PhD (Eesti Kunstimuuseum); Liina Keevallik, PhD
Opponent: Elnara Taidre, PhD (Eesti Kunstimuuseum)

Defence committee: Jaana Päeva, PhD (Head of the Defence Committee); Prof Linda Kaljundi; Taaniel Raudsepp; Prof Ülo Pikkov; Prof Indrek Ibrus (Tallinn University); Liina Unt, PhD (University of Tartu).

Thesis is available in EKA digital repository.

Abstract
I am a painter and artistic researcher whose work has, for years, been guided by strong attraction towards visual scarcity, repetition and emptiness. My doctoral thesis stems from the tension between two aspirations: the desire to reach a state of emptiness and the need to engage with painting as a material-centered and image-based art form. At a time when we are overwhelmed by an abundance of images and their rapid alternation, I ask how painting as a medium based on slow and repetitive actions relates to this.

In my autoethnographic research I serve both as the researcher and the subject of the research. The work is based on three exhibition projects: the series of paintings ‘Writing One’s / Your Name’ at the exhibition ‘Repeating Patterns’ and video narrative ‘A Postcard in Five Stills’ (2020–2021); exhibition ‘Black Mirror’ (2022); and solo exhibition ‘The Skin of Reflections’ (2023). My analysis draws on the painting diaries kept during the process of creating work for the abovementioned exhibition, using Gilles Deleuze’s three distinct syntheses of time as a framework. Through this, I demonstrate that time is layered in three ways within the process of painting: as daily rhythms and repetitive actions; as memories that emerge whilst painting; and as a striving towards emptiness and eternity, which proves to be an impossible task. I link Deleuze’s conception of time with François Jullien’s aesthetics of blandness and the Buddhist concept of Indra’s net, which describes an interwoven space-time in which every node reflects all the others.

In the context of artistic research, this is the first attempt to apply Deleuze’s conception of time in this way to make sense of the practice of painting. The work demonstrates how writing can function as a tool of inquiry for the artist: within the text, the ‘pictorial self’, the ‘diary self’ and the ‘reflective self’ engage in dialogue, revealing the same experience from three different perspectives.

The main conclusion of the research is that the apparent emptiness of the pictorial surface is, in fact, ‘full’: even in the case of the seemingly mechanical repetition of a simple image, each repetition is unique, for it conceals layers of memory, bodily rhythms and, at times, even timeless aspirations, which are revealed solely through practice. This study demonstrates how verbal and visual thinking operate in parallel within the creative process and mirror one another. During the painting process, the metaphors ‘carousel’, ‘mirror’ and ‘ivory tower’ emerged, describing, respectively, the repetitive actions of the painting process, the painting as a surface, and the artist’s studio.

Beyond my own creative work, this doctoral thesis offers three types of new insight. Firstly, it presents a model through which artists and art students can analyze the temporal layers of their creative process: the habitual present, prior knowledge (memory), and future-oriented aspirations. Secondly, the thesis proposes a conceptual framework for describing contemporary painting that goes beyond the binary oppositions characteristic of Western intellectual history (full – empty, superficial – profound). Concepts such as non-hierarchical composition, temporal and visual in-betweenness, fading surface / color tones, and the pre-existence of color and image allow us to discuss painting centered on scarcity in such a way that attention is also drawn to the process of painting and experiencing it as a viewer, as well as to its physical and sensory aspects. Thirdly, the study articulates the role of painting as a slow and material medium in an age saturated with images.

Help and search